Skip to content
Free Shipping Over $150
97,000+ Happy Customers
Vitamin D: Sun vs. Food vs. Supplement

Vitamin D: Sun vs. Food vs. Supplement

Vitamin D: Sun vs. Food vs. Supplement

Vitamin D is unusual among vitamins. Most nutrients come almost entirely from what you eat. Vitamin D can come from three very different places: your own skin, when sunlight hits it; a short list of foods; and supplements. Each source behaves differently, carries different trade-offs, and works better for some people than others.

That's why the question "should I take vitamin D?" doesn't have one answer. It depends on where you live, the season, your skin, your age, what you eat, and how much time you spend outside. It also depends on what you're hoping vitamin D will do, because the research on that has become more sobering in recent years.

This post compares all three sources using official data and the major trials. It covers how much each one can realistically provide, what limits each one, what the large trials found, and how to think about your own situation.

A disclosure up front: we sell a vitamin D3 and K2 supplement. That gives us a reason to tell you that you need it. So we've leaned on official sources and large trials, and included the findings that don't flatter supplements, too.

The numbers that matter

Before comparing sources, it helps to know the targets. According to the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements (ODS), the Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA) for vitamin D is:

  • Ages 1 to 70: 15 micrograms (600 IU) a day.

  • Over 70: 20 micrograms (800 IU) a day.

The Tolerable Upper Intake Level for adults is 100 micrograms (4,000 IU) a day. That's the highest daily intake considered unlikely to cause harm for most people.

Your vitamin D status is usually judged by measuring 25-hydroxyvitamin D, or 25(OH)D, in the blood. The ODS describes these ranges:

Blood 25(OH)D

What it generally means

Below 30 nmol/L (12 ng/mL)

Associated with deficiency, which can lead to rickets in children and osteomalacia (softened bones) in adults

30 to under 50 nmol/L (12 to under 20 ng/mL)

Generally considered inadequate for bone and overall health in healthy people

50 nmol/L (20 ng/mL) and above

Generally considered adequate for bone and overall health in healthy people

Above 125 nmol/L (50 ng/mL)

Linked to potential adverse effects, especially above 150 nmol/L (60 ng/mL)

Now here's the most revealing pair of numbers in this whole topic, both from US national survey data reported by the ODS:

  • From food alone: 94 percent of people aged one and older get less than the Estimated Average Requirement of vitamin D (10 micrograms) from food and beverages.

  • In the blood: only 5 percent were at risk of deficiency, and 18 percent at risk of inadequacy.

If almost everyone falls short from food, but most people still have adequate blood levels, the difference has to come from somewhere else. For most people, that's sunlight, along with supplements for those who take them.

Source 1: The sun

How it works

When ultraviolet B (UVB) light reaches your skin, it converts a cholesterol-related compound called 7-dehydrocholesterol into vitamin D3. The Linus Pauling Institute at Oregon State University, a widely used reference on micronutrients, calls sun exposure the primary source of vitamin D for most people.

Why it's unreliable

The catch is that sunlight is a very inconsistent source. The ODS lists season, time of day, length of day, cloud cover, smog, skin melanin content, and sunscreen among the factors that affect how much vitamin D your skin makes. Several of these deserve a closer look.

Season and latitude. The farther you live from the equator, the weaker winter sunlight is. A classic study by Webb, Kline, and Holick (Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 1988) found, as its title puts it, that "exposure to winter sunlight in Boston and Edmonton will not promote vitamin D3 synthesis in human skin."

The Linus Pauling Institute summarizes these "vitamin D winters" this way:

  • Around 40 degrees north or south: there isn't enough UVB for vitamin D synthesis from November to early March.

  • Edmonton, Canada: the vitamin D winter extends from October to April.

For a sense of scale, 40 degrees north runs roughly through Denver, Philadelphia, Madrid, and Beijing.

Age. Older skin makes less vitamin D. The Linus Pauling Institute cites research by MacLaughlin and Holick (1985) showing that aging reduces the skin's capacity to synthesize vitamin D, partly because older skin contains less of the precursor compound.

Skin pigmentation. Melanin, the pigment that gives skin its color, competes for the same UV light. According to the Linus Pauling Institute, people with darker skin may need up to ten times as long in the sun to make the same amount of vitamin D as people with lighter skin.

Time of day and weather. Midday sun is the most intense. Clouds and smog cut the amount of UVB reaching you.

Put together, that means two people standing in the same sun for the same time can make very different amounts of vitamin D. And the same person can make plenty in July and almost none in January.

Can you get too much from the sun?

Not vitamin D, at least. The ODS states that experts don't believe excessive sun exposure causes vitamin D toxicity. With prolonged exposure, the skin converts previtamin D3 into other, non-vitamin D compounds, which acts as a natural limit.

The trade-off

Sunlight is free and needs no planning. But the same UV radiation that makes vitamin D also damages skin, and that's why this source comes with a trade-off the others don't have.

The ODS notes that some expert bodies and researchers have suggested that about 5 to 30 minutes of midday sun exposure, a few times a week, usually leads to sufficient vitamin D synthesis. It also says that limiting skin exposure to sunlight and to UV radiation from tanning beds is prudent. It adds that federal agencies and national organizations advise using sunscreen with an SPF of 15 or higher.

We're not going to give you a number of minutes. The right amount varies so much with season, location, skin, and age that any single figure would be misleading for many readers. More importantly, you don't have to choose between protecting your skin and getting enough vitamin D. Food and supplements can supply it without UV damage.

One related note: our Sun Balm is a tallow-based balm, not a sunscreen. It isn't tested sun protection, and it shouldn't be used as a substitute for sunscreen.

Source 2: Food

What's actually in food

The ODS states plainly that few foods naturally contain vitamin D. Here's how the main sources compare, using ODS data:

Food

Vitamin D

Share of 15 mcg RDA

Cod liver oil, 1 tablespoon

34.0 mcg (1,360 IU)

over 200%

Rainbow trout, farmed, cooked, 3 oz

16.2 mcg (645 IU)

about 108%

Sockeye salmon, cooked, 3 oz

14.2 mcg (570 IU)

about 95%

White mushrooms, UV-exposed, raw, ½ cup

9.2 mcg (366 IU)

about 61%

Milk, 2%, vitamin D fortified, 1 cup

2.9 mcg (120 IU)

about 19%

Fortified ready-to-eat cereal, 1 serving

2.0 mcg (80 IU)

about 13%

Egg, 1 large, scrambled

1.1 mcg (44 IU)

about 7%

Light tuna, canned in water, 3 oz

1.0 mcg (40 IU)

about 7%

The percentages are our own calculations against the 15-microgram RDA for ages 1 to 70.

What that means in practice

Fatty fish are in a class of their own. A single 3-ounce serving of sockeye salmon gets you close to a full day's RDA, and farmed rainbow trout slightly exceeds it.

Beyond fatty fish, it gets difficult quickly:

  • Eggs: at 1.1 micrograms each, you'd need about 14 a day to reach 15 micrograms.

  • Fortified milk: you'd need about five cups a day.

  • UV-exposed mushrooms: these are a useful source, but they're specifically mushrooms that have been treated with UV light. Ordinary mushrooms contain far less.

Fortified foods matter a lot here. The ODS notes that almost all of the US milk supply is voluntarily fortified with about 3 micrograms per cup. But fortification varies by product and by country, so check labels rather than assuming.

Food's advantages

Food comes with no risk of sunburn, and it's very hard to overdo vitamin D from ordinary food. Fatty fish also bring other nutrients with them. The limitation is simply that, unless you eat fatty fish regularly, food alone rarely gets you to the RDA. The 94 percent figure shows how common that shortfall is.

Source 3: Supplements

D3 vs. D2

Supplements come in two main forms: vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol) and vitamin D2 (ergocalciferol). According to the ODS, both raise blood levels of 25(OH)D. But vitamin D3 raises them to a greater extent and maintains the higher levels longer than D2. Most supplements, including ours, use D3.

Taking it well

Vitamin D is fat-soluble. The ODS notes that fat in the gut enhances vitamin D absorption, though some is absorbed even without dietary fat. Taking it with a meal that contains some fat is a simple habit that helps.

On frequency, the Endocrine Society's 2024 clinical practice guideline addresses adults 50 and older who have a reason to supplement. For them, it suggests daily, lower-dose vitamin D instead of non-daily, higher doses. It found no evidence either way for people under 50.

The risk that only supplements carry

Supplements are the only one of the three sources that can realistically cause harm from too much. The ODS states that vitamin D toxicity "is almost always a result of excessive intakes of vitamin D through supplements."

Toxicity causes high blood calcium, which can lead to:

  • nausea, vomiting, and loss of appetite

  • muscle weakness

  • neuropsychiatric disturbances and pain

  • dehydration and excessive thirst

  • kidney stones

Severe cases can be life-threatening.

So it's worth adding up your total intake. Many people take vitamin D in more than one product, such as a multivitamin plus a separate vitamin D supplement. Keep the total within the 100-microgram (4,000 IU) upper limit unless a clinician has advised otherwise for a specific reason. Check the label of any vitamin D product you use, including ours, against that number.

What the big trials found

This is the part of the vitamin D story that has changed most over the past decade, and it's where we want to be especially careful.

For years, vitamin D was promoted as a supplement nearly everyone should take for a wide range of benefits. Then large, well-designed randomized trials tested that idea in generally healthy people.

VITAL and fractures

The VITAL trial gave participants 2,000 IU (50 micrograms) of vitamin D3 daily or a placebo. A 2022 analysis by LeBoff and colleagues in the New England Journal of Medicine looked at fractures in 25,871 participants:

  • Who: men aged 50 and over and women aged 55 and over, with an average age of 67.

  • Selection: they were generally healthy and not selected for low vitamin D, low bone mass, or osteoporosis.

  • Length: a median of 5.3 years.

The results:

Fracture type

Hazard ratio vs. placebo

Total fractures

0.98

Nonvertebral fractures

0.97

Hip fractures

1.01

A hazard ratio of 1.0 means no difference, so none of these showed a meaningful effect. The results didn't change based on participants' starting vitamin D levels. The authors concluded that daily vitamin D3 did not reduce fractures in generally healthy midlife and older adults.

They were also clear about the limits:

  • Who the results don't cover: people with severe vitamin D deficiency, people with osteoporosis or on osteoporosis medication, and older adults living in residential care.

  • Thin subgroups: the trial had low statistical power in those groups.

The US Preventive Services Task Force

The USPSTF's 2018 recommendation on fracture prevention in community-dwelling adults reached a similar position:

  • Postmenopausal women, low doses: it recommends against daily supplementation with 400 IU or less of vitamin D and 1,000 milligrams or less of calcium for preventing fractures (a grade D recommendation).

  • Higher doses, and men and premenopausal women: it found the evidence insufficient to judge benefits and harms.

Its recommendations don't apply to people with a history of osteoporotic fractures, an increased risk of falls, osteoporosis, or vitamin D deficiency.

The Endocrine Society's 2024 guideline

The Endocrine Society's 2024 guideline on vitamin D for the prevention of disease (Demay and colleagues, Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism) is the most recent major guidance. For generally healthy adults, it suggests:

  • Under 50: against taking vitamin D above the RDA.

  • Aged 50 to 74: against routine supplementation.

  • Under 75: against routine blood testing for vitamin D.

It does suggest supplementation for:

  • children and teenagers aged 1 to 18

  • adults aged 75 and older

  • pregnancy

  • certain people with specific medical risk factors

The guideline also notes that blood levels that provide outcome-specific benefits haven't been established in clinical trials, and that the optimal intake for disease prevention remains uncertain.

What this means

Taken together, these findings point to a clear message. Vitamin D supplements are a tool for meeting your needs when sun and food don't. They aren't a proven way to gain extra protection when you're already getting enough.

That's an important distinction, and it's one we think the supplement industry, us included, should state more plainly. These guidelines are about generally healthy people. They don't change advice for anyone a clinician is treating for deficiency or another condition.

Side by side

Sun

  • How much it provides: often the main source, but highly variable.

  • Main limits: season, latitude, age, skin pigmentation, weather, and time of day. In winter at higher latitudes, it can be close to zero.

  • Risk of too much vitamin D: no. The skin limits production.

  • Other risks: UV damage to skin.

  • Best for: people with regular outdoor time in summer, at lower latitudes.

Food

  • How much it provides: low, except for fatty fish and some fortified foods.

  • Main limits: few foods contain it. 94 percent of people fall short from food alone.

  • Risk of too much vitamin D: very unlikely from ordinary food.

  • Other risks: none to speak of.

  • Best for: regular fatty fish eaters, and topping up.

Supplements

  • How much it provides: precise, as much as you choose.

  • Main limits: you have to remember them, and quality varies.

  • Risk of too much vitamin D: yes. Almost all toxicity comes from supplements.

  • Other risks: high blood calcium at excessive doses.

  • Best for: people whose sun exposure and diet fall short, and groups the guidelines specifically identify.

How to think about your own situation

Start with your sun exposure, honestly. Consider your latitude, the season, how much time you spend outdoors, your age, and your skin tone. If you live far from the equator, it's winter, you're mostly indoors, you're older, or you have darker skin, the sun is probably supplying less than you think.

Then look at your diet. Do you eat fatty fish like salmon or trout regularly? Do you drink fortified milk or eat other fortified foods? If not, food is likely providing only a small fraction of the RDA.

If both fall short, a supplement is a reasonable way to fill the gap. Aim to meet the RDA, not to megadose. Choose vitamin D3, take it with a meal that contains some fat, and keep your total from all sources within the 4,000 IU upper limit unless a clinician advises otherwise.

Don't expect a supplement to do more than fill a gap. The largest trials in generally healthy people haven't found that extra vitamin D reduces fractures when you're already getting enough.

Talk to a clinician about testing if you have a reason. The Endocrine Society suggests against routine testing for healthy adults under 75. But if you have symptoms, a medical condition, take medications that affect vitamin D, or fall into one of the groups the guidelines identify, testing and personalized advice make sense.

Where our product fits

We sell a vitamin D3 supplement combined with vitamin K2, which we've written about separately. Based on everything above, here's how we'd describe its role. It's a convenient way to meet your vitamin D needs if your sun exposure and diet fall short, which is common in winter, at higher latitudes, and for people who spend most of their time indoors. It's not a substitute for medical care, and the evidence doesn't support taking it to get extra protection if your levels are already adequate.

We haven't yet published batch testing for our D3 and K2 product. We'll share it once that documentation is complete, as we have for our other products.

The honest summary

Vitamin D can come from sun, food, or supplements, and each has a different role.

The sun is the main source for most people, but it's highly variable. Winter sunlight at higher latitudes may produce almost none, older skin makes less, and darker skin may need up to ten times as long. It can't cause vitamin D toxicity, but it does carry the risk of UV damage, and limiting exposure is prudent.

Food contains surprisingly little vitamin D, apart from fatty fish and fortified foods. A 3-ounce serving of salmon provides close to a full day's RDA. Most other foods provide a small fraction, and 94 percent of people fall short from food alone.

Supplements are precise and reliable, and vitamin D3 raises blood levels more effectively than D2. But they're also the only source that commonly causes toxicity, so staying within the 4,000 IU upper limit matters. And the largest trials in generally healthy people found that 2,000 IU a day did not reduce fractures.

So the goal isn't to choose one source. It's to make sure that, between sun, food, and if needed a supplement, you're meeting your needs, without expecting more vitamin D to do things the evidence hasn't shown.

 


 

References

  1. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Vitamin D: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals.

  2. Webb AR, Kline L, Holick MF. Influence of season and latitude on the cutaneous synthesis of vitamin D3: exposure to winter sunlight in Boston and Edmonton will not promote vitamin D3 synthesis in human skin. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism. 1988;67:373-378.

  3. Linus Pauling Institute, Oregon State University. Micronutrient Information Center: Vitamin D and Skin Health. (Summarizes research including MacLaughlin and Holick, 1985, on aging and vitamin D synthesis.)

  4. LeBoff MS, Chou SH, et al. Supplemental vitamin D and incident fractures in midlife and older adults. New England Journal of Medicine. 2022. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa2202106

  5. US Preventive Services Task Force. Vitamin D, Calcium, or Combined Supplementation for the Primary Prevention of Fractures in Community-Dwelling Adults: Preventive Medication. April 17, 2018.

  6. Demay MB, Pittas AG, Bikle DD, et al. Vitamin D for the prevention of disease: an Endocrine Society clinical practice guideline. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism. 2024. doi:10.1210/clinem/dgae290

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Experience the PÜR-ISHH Standard

Stop settling for synthetic fillers, artificial flavors, and hidden toxins. Upgrade your daily routine with our uncompromising, 100% clean formulas.

Available on Amazon

Shop Now
Purishh